Mortgage Fraud 101 | The Section 1(3) Point and the Estoppel Issue
Referring to the proper making and delivery of mortgage deeds, section 1 (3) of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 provides that:
“An instrument is validly executed as a deed by an individual if, and only if, (a) it is signed – (i) by him in the presence of a witness who attests his signature.”
Furthermore, it was affirmed by the Adjudicator in Garguilo v Jon Howard Gershinson & Anr [2012] EWLandRA 2011_0377 that the worditin this section must refer to the complete deed.
In other words, the entire document and not merely the execution page or any other page, must be signed in the presence of a witness, who must attest to the signature’s validity, as per the rules regarding the strict formalities for the execution and delivery of deeds, described by the learned Underhill J in R [Mercury Tax Group] v HMRC [2008].
Moreover, by way of section 52(1) Law of Property Act 1925, all conveyances of land are void for the purpose of creating a legal estate in land unless they are properly made by deed.
The Garguilo Case
In Garguilo, Mr and Mrs Garguilo submitted that even if the signatory pages of a disputed lease purportedly operating as a deed were, as found, executed separately and inserted into the lease at a later date, this invalidates the instrument as a matter of law.
The point had already been considered by Underhill J in Mercury, in which the claimants sought judicial review of the decision of HMRC to seek warrants to search their offices and the decision of the Crown Court to grant the warrants.
R [Mercury Tax Group] v HMRC [2008]
HMRC’s case was that the scheme (trust deed) in question was flawed and that the claimants sought dishonestly to conceal the flaws. The judge therefore had to consider whether the purported deed was flawed, as there were differences between the drafts and the final versions.
The court considered as an additional factor that each of the three key documents was intended to be a deed. Noting section 1(3) Underhill J said:
“Mr Bird submitted, and I agree, that that language necessarily involves that the signature and attestation must form part of the same physical document (the ‘it’) referred to at (a) which constitutes the deed.” [40].
He continued:
“I accept that the flaws on which HMRC rely are essentially formal. But I see nothing wrong in applying a strict test of formality to the validity of the agreements with which we are concerned in this case. The entire raison d’être is to create – and demonstrably to create – a series of formal legal relationships: if they do not do that, they do nothing.”
Landmark Decision
The Adjudicator in Garguilo therefore found that section 1(3) clearly provides that the signature and attestation must form part of the physical instrument at the moment of signing and that the policy argument is that the signature should reflect the proper agreement at the time of execution.
It was therefore held that if the signature is obtained separately from the attestation and/or from other documents that purportedly make up the deed, the maker of a disposition cannot be sure of the terms of the deed and the risk of fraud or mistake remains.
The question must always be whether a valid signature page and other relevant pages formed part of the same complete physical document at the moment of execution. That will be a question of fact in each case.
However, is also more than arguable that the same legal policy must be applied to mortgage deeds which are signed without being dated, which applies to every UK mortgage for the past five decades.
No Estoppel
Somewhat inevitably, the issue of estoppel was raised by the respondents in opposition to the Garguilo points.
However, it was held that the lack of a (valid) signature could not be cured by raising the issue of estoppel.
This point was confirmed by principles at the heart of the judgment of Lady Justice Arden in Herbert -v- Doyle (October 2010):
“Applying what Lord Walker said in relation to proprietary estoppel also to constructive trust… if the parties intend to make a formal agreement setting out the terms on which one or more of the parties is to acquire an interest in property … neither party can rely on constructive trust as a means of enforcing their original agreement. In other words, at least in those situations, if their agreement (which does not comply with section 2(1)) is incomplete, they cannot utilise the doctrine of proprietary estoppel or the doctrine of constructive trust to make their agreement binding on the other party by virtue of section 2(5) of the 1989 Act …” (para #57).
Binding Precedent
Having consistently argued these points from October 2010, on the 21st of July 2014, my family’s property trust’s defence of a ~Bank of Scotland claim for an allegedly outstanding £1.87 M was emphatically sustained before HHJ Behrens at Leeds High Court.
Behrens declared that the trustees were not estopped from relying upon the argument that a mortgage deed is illegal and void, if it fails to comply with the provisions of section 1(3) of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989, under section 52(1) of the Law of Property Act 1925.
This High Court ruling immediately became binding on all mortgage-related proceedings and is cited as Bank of Scotland plc v Waugh & Others [2014].
The main point that was taken in our case became known as the Section 1(3) point. It also provided the first of the TGBMS Grounds, in our on-going class actions to end UK mortgage fraud.
{"id":null,"mode":"button","open_style":"in_modal","currency_code":"GBP","currency_symbol":"\u00a3","currency_type":"decimal","blank_flag_url":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/wp-content\/plugins\/tip-jar-wp\/\/assets\/images\/flags\/blank.gif","flag_sprite_url":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/wp-content\/plugins\/tip-jar-wp\/\/assets\/images\/flags\/flags.png","default_amount":1200,"top_media_type":"featured_image","featured_image_url":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/09\/MOB-200x150.jpg","featured_embed":"","header_media":null,"file_download_attachment_data":null,"recurring_options_enabled":true,"recurring_options":{"never":{"selected":true,"after_output":"One time only"},"weekly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every week"},"monthly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every month"},"yearly":{"selected":false,"after_output":"Every year"}},"strings":{"current_user_email":"","current_user_name":"","link_text":"Tip Some Coin","complete_payment_button_error_text":"Check info and try again","payment_verb":"Tip Now","payment_request_label":"The Bernician","form_has_an_error":"Please check and fix the errors above","general_server_error":"Something isn't working right at the moment. Please try again.","form_title":"Tip The Bernician Some Coin","form_subtitle":"Show your appreciation for The Bernician's work by donating whatever you can afford in the tips jar.","currency_search_text":"Country or Currency here","other_payment_option":"Other payment option","manage_payments_button_text":"Manage your payments","thank_you_message":"Thank you for being a supporter of The Bernician's work. Much appreciated.","payment_confirmation_title":"The Bernician","receipt_title":"Your Receipt","print_receipt":"Print Receipt","email_receipt":"Email Receipt","email_receipt_sending":"Sending receipt...","email_receipt_success":"Email receipt successfully sent","email_receipt_failed":"Email receipt failed to send. Please try again.","receipt_payee":"Paid to","receipt_statement_descriptor":"This will show up on your statement as","receipt_date":"Date","receipt_transaction_id":"Transaction ID","receipt_transaction_amount":"Amount","refund_payer":"Refund from","login":"Log in to manage your payments","manage_payments":"Manage Payments","transactions_title":"Your Transactions","transaction_title":"Transaction Receipt","transaction_period":"Plan Period","arrangements_title":"Your Plans","arrangement_title":"Manage Plan","arrangement_details":"Plan Details","arrangement_id_title":"Plan ID","arrangement_payment_method_title":"Payment Method","arrangement_amount_title":"Plan Amount","arrangement_renewal_title":"Next renewal date","arrangement_action_cancel":"Cancel Plan","arrangement_action_cant_cancel":"Cancelling is currently not available.","arrangement_action_cancel_double":"Are you sure you'd like to cancel?","arrangement_cancelling":"Cancelling Plan...","arrangement_cancelled":"Plan Cancelled","arrangement_failed_to_cancel":"Failed to cancel plan","back_to_plans":"\u2190 Back to Plans","update_payment_method_verb":"Update","sca_auth_description":"Your have a pending renewal payment which requires authorization.","sca_auth_verb":"Authorize renewal payment","sca_authing_verb":"Authorizing payment","sca_authed_verb":"Payment successfully authorized!","sca_auth_failed":"Unable to authorize! Please try again.","login_button_text":"Log in","login_form_has_an_error":"Please check and fix the errors above","uppercase_search":"Search","lowercase_search":"search","uppercase_page":"Page","lowercase_page":"page","uppercase_items":"Items","lowercase_items":"items","uppercase_per":"Per","lowercase_per":"per","uppercase_of":"Of","lowercase_of":"of","back":"Back to plans","zip_code_placeholder":"Zip\/Postal Code","download_file_button_text":"Download File","input_field_instructions":{"tip_amount":{"placeholder_text":"How much would you like to tip?","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"How much would you like to tip? Choose any currency."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"How much would you like to tip? Choose any currency."},"invalid_curency":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please choose a valid currency."}},"recurring":{"placeholder_text":"Recurring","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"How often would you like to give this?"}},"name":{"placeholder_text":"Name on Credit Card","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter the name on your card."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter the name on your card."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please enter the name on your card."}},"privacy_policy":{"terms_title":"Terms and conditions","terms_body":null,"terms_show_text":"View Terms","terms_hide_text":"Hide Terms","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"I agree to the terms."},"unchecked":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Please agree to the terms."},"checked":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"I agree to the terms."}},"email":{"placeholder_text":"Your email address","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email address"},"not_an_email_address":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Make sure you have entered a valid email address"}},"note_with_tip":{"placeholder_text":"Your note here...","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"empty":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"not_empty_initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Attach a note to your tip (optional)"},"saving":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Saving note..."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Note successfully saved!"},"error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Unable to save note note at this time. Please try again."}},"email_for_login_code":{"placeholder_text":"Your email address","initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your email to log in."}},"login_code":{"initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"success":{"instruction_type":"success","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"blank":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Check your email and enter the login code."}},"stripe_all_in_one":{"initial":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"empty":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"success":{"instruction_type":"normal","instruction_message":"Enter your credit card details here."},"invalid_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is not a valid credit card number."},"invalid_expiry_month":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration month is invalid."},"invalid_expiry_year":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration year is invalid."},"invalid_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is invalid."},"incorrect_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is incorrect."},"incomplete_number":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card number is incomplete."},"incomplete_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is incomplete."},"incomplete_expiry":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration date is incomplete."},"incomplete_zip":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's zip code is incomplete."},"expired_card":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card has expired."},"incorrect_cvc":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's security code is incorrect."},"incorrect_zip":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's zip code failed validation."},"invalid_expiry_year_past":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card's expiration year is in the past"},"card_declined":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The card was declined."},"missing":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"There is no card on a customer that is being charged."},"processing_error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"An error occurred while processing the card."},"invalid_request_error":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"Unable to process this payment, please try again or use alternative method."},"invalid_sofort_country":{"instruction_type":"error","instruction_message":"The billing country is not accepted by SOFORT. Please try another country."}}}},"fetched_oembed_html":false}
{"date_format":"jS F Y","time_format":"g:i a","wordpress_permalink_only":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/mortgage-fraud-101-the-section-13-argument-and-the-estoppel-issue\/","all_default_visual_states":"inherit","modal_visual_state":false,"user_is_logged_in":false,"stripe_api_key":"pk_live_MwQiW3XkwrmT05UCY2ULM4JZ00QrNZsHfV","stripe_account_country_code":"GB","setup_link":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/wp-admin\/admin.php?page=tip-jar-wp&mpwpadmin1=welcome&mpwpadmin_lightbox=do_wizard_health_check","close_button_url":"https:\/\/www.thebernician.net\/wp-content\/plugins\/tip-jar-wp\/\/assets\/images\/closebtn.png"}